MLB The Show 25: A Solid Iteration review 2025

Yo what up gamers Its your boy Leo straight outta LA here to drop some knowledge on the freshest baseball sim to hit the streets MLB The Show 25 For all you diehard fans and even the newbies lookin to step up to the plate this ones a solid pick.

Ive been slingin game reviews for a grip now so trust me when I say I know whats good. You can find me kickin it at 3215 Overland Ave Los Angeles California(CA) 90034. Lets dive into what makes this game the real deal.

Steppin Up to the Plate The Gameplay is Still Fire

Listen the core of MLB The Show 25? Its still straightup amazing. San Diego Studio has been cookin up this formula for years and theyve practically perfected it.

Seriously its tough to imagine a baseball game playin any smoother. You get a whole menu of options to tweak the experience exactly how you want it. Wanna keep it chill and casual?

You got it. Craving that super realistic vibe? They got you covered too. Peep this theres even dynamic difficulty that changes on the fly based on how youre playin.

Thats slick As a gamer enthusiast with a couple of years of reviewing under my belt Ive seen a lot of sports sims and the customization here is toptier.

You can even choose your batting style. Go old school with the face buttons or try the stickflick input that The Show made famous.

Bottom line in MLB The Show 25 you can mess with practically everything to fit your own style. I personally was vibin with the stick input for hittin and the dynamic difficulty.

It just felt right ya know? The game gives you nearfull control and thats whats up.

Droppin Into the Modes So Much to Explore Its Crazy

Once you get your controls dialed in MLB The Show 25 throws a dizzying amount of game modes at you. Longtime fans? Youll likely beeline for your goto favorites.

And dont sweat it all the popular modes are back and better than ever. Trust me as someone whos spent countless hours in sports games the amount of content here is seriously impressive.

Road to the Show From High School Hero to Hall of Famer

Since way back in 2006 the OG MLB The Show had this mode called Road to the Show. The concept is simple but addictive you create a single player and try to turn them into a legendary baseball icon.

But MLB The Show 25 takes it to a whole new level. Now you start your journey way back in high school This makes the whole rise to the Majors feel even more rewarding. Youre livin your players career from the jump.

They give you total freedom when makin your character. We talkin gender positions starting stats the works. MLB The Show 25 has crazy character customization.

You can even scan your own face if you want to see your mug in the game. Sometimes it looks kinda goofy but after a few tries you can get it pretty close.

As a gamer who loves to get immersed in a role the level of customization here is a major plus.

MLB The Show 25 even throws in some RPG elements. Were talkin dialogue options gear that boosts your stats and a whole leveling system.

You earn XP for doin good stuff during games. Plus you can snag bonus XP and tokens for crushin challenges.

Road to the Show in MLB The Show 25 is like always a deep and super engaging experience. Its easy to get invested in your created player.

Sure the lack of voice acting is a little weird and some of the written dialogue can be cheesy.

But the main focus is still on the gameplay and that part is still a blast.

They even added a new firstperson mode for Road to the Show I stuck with the regular view but its cool to see them tryin new things. Expanding on that firstperson view in future games could be sick.

Diamond Dynasty Build Your Dream Team

Road to the Show will keep you busy for hours but thats just the tip of the iceberg fam. The other main mode thatll probably eat up most of your time is Diamond Dynasty.

Its the trading card game mode that every sports game has these days. The goal? Collect player cards and build the ultimate squad. This year Diamond Dynasty ditched those restrictive seasons.

That makes it way more appealing for real. Look Im not always the biggest fan of these microtransaction fueled modes.

But MLB The Show has consistently done it better than most. And that continues with MLB The Show 25. All the usual ways to play and earn rewards are back.

And they even dropped a fresh new addition. As someone who appreciates fair monetization in games MLB The Shows approach to Diamond Dynasty is commendable.

Diamond Quest A Fresh Spin on Dynasty

Peep this new mode Diamond Quest. Its a fresh addition to the Diamond Dynasty lineup in MLB The Show 25. You roll a die and move around a game board.

Along the way you tackle different challenges to earn rewards and dodge penalties. Its got this interesting roguelike vibe. Its a fun new way to shake things up in Diamond Dynasty.

Just Play Ball Standard Games and Multiplayer

Of course if you just wanna jump into a regular baseball game MLB The Show 25 has you covered. You can play against the computer battle it out in local multiplayer with your friends or take your skills online.

The core baseball gameplay is the heart of this game. And like I said before its still topnotch. Lets be real The Show is basically the only big baseball sim out there. So its a W for us fans that its consistently a high quality game every year.

Lookin Good But Could Be Even Better

Alright lets keep it 100. One of the slight bummers with MLB The Show 25 is that it doesnt have some massive new feature or game mode that makes it a must buy if youve already sunk a ton of hours into previous games.

Its more of an upgrade than a total transformation. It delivers an experience thats on par with the older games without really pushing the envelope. And while the game can look seriously good with realistic lighting helmet reflections and dirt flyin the graphics dont feel like a huge leap.

Even though it skipped the older consoles this year you could probably still run this on a PS4 or Xbox One. You still see some weird stuff like hair clipping through heads and those city backgrounds in stadiums can look kinda weak.

As a visual enthusiast I always appreciate graphical improvements and while MLB The Show 25 looks good its not mindblowing…

The Verdict Solid as Always

Look all those annual sports games have those entries that focus on polishin whats already there instead of tryin wild new stuff. MLB The Show 25 definitely falls into that category.

Most of whats here is great and will give baseball fans their moneys worth and then some.

But if youre lookin for somethin totally different you might be a little let down. Still you gotta give it up for the sheer amount of content in MLB The Show 25.

The core gameplay is a blast and it really captures the feel of MLB. MLB The Show 25 is more of the same but when the same is this good its hard to complain.

Metacritic shows a Meta score of 83 based on 22 critic reviews for the PlayStation 5 version indicating generally favorable reviews.

Impulse gamer gave it a 90 praising the refined and immersive experience on the PS5. Screen Rant also gave it a high score highlighting its ability to let players live out their baseball dreams. User reviews on Metacritic are a bit more mixed with an average score of 5.8.

One user called it a triumph for baseball fans praising the gameplay new hitting mechanic overhauled Road to the Show and the changes to Diamond Dynasty.

Another user loved the removal of sets and seasons in Diamond Dynasty. However some users expressed disappointment feeling the game lacked significant changes and that the animations felt outdated.

One user even said it was the worst in years due to repetitive text in RTTS and a disliked UI change.

MLB The Show 25 celebrates the series 20th anniversary which is a major milestone. Its available on PlayStation 5 Nintendo Switch and Xbox Series X.

San Diego Studio developed it and Sony Interactive Entertainment published it. Its a straightup baseball sim.

Final Thoughts from Your LA Gamer

Overall MLB The Show 25 is a solid addition to the franchise. It refines an already excellent formula with smart improvements.

Whether youre a diehard baseball head or just lookin for a dope sports game this ones worth checkin out. It might not reinvent the wheel but it delivers a polished and fun baseball experience.

For me Leo your friendly neighborhood gamer from LA its another year of deep dives into Road to the Show and tryin to build that ultimate Diamond Dynasty squad. Catch yall on the digital diamond..

Resource

https://www.metacritic.com/game/mlb-the-show-25/

https://gamerant.com/mlb-the-show-25-review/

All Images and featured image used in this article was owned by gamerant and respective creators..

Leave a Comment